Secret Intelligence (Chapter 10)

p. 165, illegals: There is evidence that the use of ‘illegals’ is increasing. This is a result of the large number of expulsions of intelligence officers with diplomatic cover (‘legals’) produced by the serious deterioration in relations between Russia and the NATO powers following Putin’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.

p. 165, ‘typical diplomatic ranks’: It is worth recording the view on this of the highly regarded veteran BBC world affairs reporter, John Simpson, albeit one that appears in his 2021 novel Our Friends in Beijing (see Further reading below). Referring to Raj Harish, an important character in the book, he says that ‘He had one of those flimsy cover jobs at the British embassy [in Beijing]: deputy information officer, or third commerecial attaché, or something. If you want to see who’s in the British intelligence game, look at their titles. They’re always a couple of steps below the level you’d expect for their age and seniority.’ (p. 111)
Rather confirming this is the evidence of the SIS station in the British Embassy in Tehran in 1952. The head of station in the embassy was former Special Operations Executive officer C. M. (‘Monty’) Woodhouse, who had cover as 2nd Secretary (Information), according to the Foreign Office List for that year. However, he had only just arrived and most of the station’s key local agents were activated and run by R. C. (‘Robin’) Zaehner, a scholar and fluent Persian-speaker who had seen much service as an SIS officer for the embassy since 1943. (The exception was a high-level ‘walk-in’ codenamed ‘Omar’ whom Woodhouse ran himself.) According to The English Job, by former British foreign secretary Jack Straw, in 1952 Zaehner had the rank of ‘acting counsellor’ in the embassy. There is no mention of him in the Foreign Office List for these years, so this title was presumably what was known as a ‘local rank’ – a label solely designed to give comfort to the wearer and impress the locals. As for the rest of the ‘station’ in the embassy, whether this consisted of one or more SIS officers or simply diplomats allotted to Woodhouse, is not clear. In any event, in his memoirs, Something Ventured, he says that ‘My own assets when I took up a nominal post in our Embassy were considerable … Three or four able young men … specialized in intelligence on Iran and the Communists. Another cultivated leading Iranians who were hostile to Mussaddiq [the prime minister]. Another conducted a useful liaison, approved by the Shah, with the chief of the Security Police, who was well informed about the Tudeh Party [the Iranian Communist party].’ The Oriental Counsellor, Assistant Oriental Secretary, 1st Secretary (Information), and the other 2nd Secretary (Information) would seem to be likely candidates for these intelligence specialists. By way of a footnote, the SIS station in the British Embassy in Tehran was crippled in October 1952 when Iran severed diplomatic relations with Britain but Woodhouse and his ‘team’ were able to preserve contact with their main agents in Tehran from a new office set up ‘under cover’ of the British military’s GHQ on Cyprus. In 1953 a joint SIS-CIA stimulated coup brought down the popular Iranian prime minister, Mohammad Mossadegh, chiefly because he had nationalized the rapacious and mule-headed Anglo-Iranian Oil Company (today BP) but ostensibly because he was believed to be opening the gates to a Soviet takeover of Iran.

p. 166, Box 10.3: Another SIS officer who served as consul-general in Hanoi during the Vietnam War was Brian Stewart, I have just learned from his Why Spy? (Ch. 2) and his son Rory Stewart, The Marches, p. 18  (see Further Reading below). (Rory is now best known for his brilliant podcast with Alistair Campbell, ‘The Rest is Politics’.) In the Second World War, Brian had been an officer in the Black Watch, the 3rd Battalion of the Royal Regiment of Scotland and most feared infantry in the British Army. Afterwards he served for twelve years in the Malayan civil service, and on Malaya’s independence in 1957 joined SIS. Thereafter, with diplomatic cover as second secretary, he served at British missions in Rangoon and Peking, and then as consul-general (according to him) or first secretary (according to The Diplomatic Service List, 1972) at Shanghai, and then first secretary at Manila, the Foreign Office, and Kuala Lumpur before being transferred to Hanoi with the rank of consul-general in August 1967, remaining there until some time in the following year, thereby overlapping with the Tet Offensive in January. In Why Spy? Brian says the Hanoi government refused to recognise him as a consular officer (addressing him simply as ‘Mr Stewart’ and on one occasion arresting and imprisoning him) and speculated that it tolerated this post of America’s closest ally because it thought it could do little harm and might one day ‘provide a useful link to Britain’ (p. 26). (The North Vietnamese would have been aware that the Labour government in Britain had refused the American request to send troops to Vietnam.) He was already fluent in several Asiatic languages and quickly picked up basic Vietnamese; accordingly, he learned much from being on the spot, and reported that North Vietnamese morale remained high. He eventually became de facto deputy to the chief of SIS. My guess now is that all, or at least most, of these British ‘consuls-general’ in Hanoi were SIS officers.

p. 173 (Second to be noted …), secret service alliances and liaisons: Other plausible liaisons if not alliances are those between Russia and China and Russia and Iran claimed in 2023 by SVR chief Sergey Naryshkin, although it clearly suits the Kremlin to advertise – and possibly exaggerate – the strength of these relationships.

pp. 173-4, incl. Box 10.7: It will be interesting to see if the Five Eyes’ Alliance, in particular the NSA-GCHQ intimacy within it, helps to preserve good relations between the looming Trump-Musk co-regency in the United States and its hitherto closest allies. A bad sign is President-elect Trump’s long nurtured hostility to America’s ‘deep state’, prominent in which is the CIA; a good sign is his nomination to be its head of John Ratcliffe.

p. 174, intel officers as special envoys: See Ch. 15 updating page.

Further reading

Anadolu Agency [Turkey], ‘Intelligence ties with China at “unprecedented” level, says Russian spy chief’, 17 January 2023

Cater, Leonie, ‘Netherlands orders expulsion of Russian diplomats’, Politico, 18 February 2023

Clogg, Richard, ‘Woodhouse, Christopher Montague [Monty], fifth Baron Terrington (1917–2001)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, 08 January 2009

Cornwell, Tim (ed), A Private Spy: The Letters of John le Carré (Penguin Books, 2023), first pub. Viking 2022. Not of great value for this subject but still worth using via the Index, which turns up interesting tit-bits.

Der Standard, Parliamentary Question: ‘Number of Russian diplomats in Vienna has decreased since 2022, according to Foreign Minister’, 12 May 202

Dettmer, Jamie, ‘Russian spies rebound in Europe’, Politico, 4 April 2023

Duxbury, Charlie, ‘Russia’s diplomatic clash with Europe flares in Estonia: A mutual expelling of ambassadors is putting into question the value of European countries’ diplomatic links with the Kremlin’, Politico, 26 March, 2023

Guardian staff, ‘Moldova expels 45 Russian diplomats and embassy staff, citing years of “hostile actions”’, 27 July 2023

Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament, ‘China’, HC1605, 13 July 2023

Karnitschnig, Matthew, ‘How Putin hijacked Austria’s spy service — and is now gunning for its government’, Politico, 24 May 2024

Riehle, Kevin, ‘The History and Continuing Relevance of Soviet Bloc Illegal Intelligence Operatives’, 5 January 2023, a blog post of the History and Public Policy Forum (Wilson Center)

Security Service, UK (MI5), ‘How Spies Operate’

Simpson, John, A Mad World, My Masters: Tales from a Traveller’s Life (Pan Books, 2001), Ch. 4 (‘Spies’), useful on the differences between journalists and intelligence officers by the highly respected BBC world affairs editor

– – – -, Our Friends in Beijing (John Murray, 2021), pb. ed. 2022

Stewart, Brian and Samantha Newbery, Why Spy? The art of intelligence (Hurst, 2015)

Stewart, Rory, The Marches: Border walks with my father (Vintage, 2017)

Straw, Jack, The English Job: Understanding Iran and why it distrusts Britain (Biteback, 2019), Ch. 10 (‘Spooks and Coups’)

Walker, Shaun, ‘The ‘ordinary’ family at No 35: suspected Russian spies await trial in Slovenia’, The Guardian, 24 March 2023

Wikipedia, ‘Robert Charles Zaehner’

Wintour, Patrick, ‘Spy games: expulsion of diplomats shines light on Russian espionage’, The Guardian, 15 April 2022

Woodhouse, C. M., Something Ventured (Granada, 1982). According to the ODNB essay on Woodhouse, his revelations about the Mossadegh affair in this memoir ‘earned him a mild rebuke from SIS.’